Checks Unlimited vs Checkomatic: A Detailed Comparison

Company Overview

Checks Unlimited and Checkomatic are both direct-to-consumer check printers, but they differ significantly in pricing structure, turnaround time, and checkout experience. This comparison examines the key differences to help you choose between them.

Checks Unlimited is a division of Deluxe Corporation, one of the largest check manufacturers in the United States. Checkomatic is an independent check printer that positions itself as a transparent, fee-free alternative.

Pricing and Fees

Checks Unlimited's personal checks start at approximately $22.44 per box, with handling fees now included in the listed price. Business checks list at approximately $92.44 per box, plus a $12.50 per-order handling fee. Checkomatic advertises direct manufacturer pricing with no per-order handling fees, according to publicly available comparisons.

For business buyers, the difference in fee structure can be significant across multiple reorder cycles. A $12.50 handling fee on every business order adds up over time. Compare total costs (including all fees and shipping) before deciding.

Turnaround Time

Checks Unlimited's standard untrackable shipping may take up to 15 business days total (printing plus shipping). Checkomatic's standard turnaround is 3–5 business days from proof approval, with rush delivery available. If you need checks quickly, Checkomatic's standard turnaround is significantly faster.

Logo Printing

Checks Unlimited offers logo printing as an optional paid feature on business check formats. Checkomatic includes free black-and-white logo printing on every personal and business check order with no setup fee. For businesses that want their logo on their checks, this difference in cost can be meaningful across multiple reorders.

Checkout Experience

Some publicly available customer feedback has noted that Checks Unlimited's checkout includes pre-selected add-on subscriptions requiring active opt-out. Checkomatic's checkout, according to comparisons, does not include pre-selected add-ons. If you're sensitive to checkout friction, this is an important difference.

Product Range

Checks Unlimited offers over 200 personal check designs, a large accessories catalog, and business checks. Checkomatic offers a broader range of blank check stock and business check formats but has a smaller personal check design catalog. If design variety is your priority, Checks Unlimited has the edge. If functional range and fee transparency matter more, Checkomatic is worth considering.

Which Is Better for You?

Choose Checks Unlimited if you want a large design catalog, licensed themes, and the backing of Deluxe Corporation. Choose Checkomatic if you prioritize no handling fees, free logo printing, faster standard turnaround, and a checkout without pre-selected add-ons. Compare total costs on both official websites before ordering.